What gets replies
Named person vs generic inbox
No real difference yet.
Named person11%
58 of 523 replied · 6 won
Generic inbox12%
31 of 256 replied · 2 won
Generic = info@, press@, partnerships@ and similar shared addresses.
Mass template vs one-off
One-off gets 2.0x the reply rate of mass template.
One-off16%
52 of 323 replied · 6 won
Mass template8%
37 of 456 replied · 2 won
Mass template = the same subject and opening sent to 5+ brands. A templated email can still have a personal line further down.
Follow-ups
8 replies came only after a follow-up. Follow-ups go to brands that ignored the first email, so their rate will always look lower; they still win extra replies.
No follow-up12%
81 of 694 replied · 7 won
1 follow-up8%
6 of 80 replied · 1 won
2+ follow-ups50%
2 of 4 replied · small sample
9% of replies (8 of 89) came only after a follow-up. Rows count follow-ups sent before the brand replied, or in total if they never did.
Warm vs cold
Not enough pitches on both sides to compare yet.
Warm20%
5 of 25 replied · small sample
Cold11%
84 of 754 replied · 8 won
Warm = alum or FIA connection, past sponsor, someone you met, a referral, or a brand that replied in an earlier season. Fix any row by hand in its details.
Team and pipeline
By board member
SentRepliedReply rate
Maddie Cheng Best
32/168
19%1 won
Jasmine Pradhana
22/152
14%1 won
Gemma Miller
10/130
8%1 won
Tatjana Castelein
4/100
4%1 won
Gabrielle Desdune
5/57
9%
Lucas Damasco
3/55
5%1 won
Emily Chang
3/16
19%3 won
Gabriela Franklin
1/15
7%
Pipeline
Committed value by owner
Maddie Cheng
6 deals
$5,050
Jasmine Pradhana
2 deals
$2,012
Tatjana Castelein
1 deal
$1,000
Value only counts once you enter it on a deal.
By outreach type
SentRepliedReply rate
Sponsorship Best
53/457
12%3 won
VIP invite
21/175
12%4 won
Recruiter Reception
7/77
9%1 won
By season
SentRepliedReply rate
Spring 2026 Best
79/624
13%7 won
Gray means fewer than 30 pitches, too few to call a pattern. "Best" and the takeaways weigh reply rate by volume, so a high rate on a handful of emails doesn't win. Won counts only after you confirm it.